1. Super-Heroes



    Traffic Light Cards


     

    Traffic Light Cards are a variation on the popular “traffic lighting” strategy used in the United Kingdom (Black et al., 2003). The traffic light icons-red-,yellow-, and green-colored “lights”-are used to represent levels of student understanding. Students are given three different-colored cards, asked to self-assess their understanding about a concept or skill they are learning, and hold up the card that best matches their understanding: green-“I understand this very well,” yellow-“I understand most of it but could use a little help,” and red-“Help. I don’t get it.”

     

     


    Thumps Up and Thumbs Down

     


    A teacher frequently reads aloud a prepared statement, and then asks students to hold their hands under their chins and signify whether the statement is true or false by showing a “thumbs-up” for true or a “thumbs-down” for false. Depending on the number of students who respond incorrectly the teacher may have students present arguments for both sides, they may pair students and ask them to discuss the concept further, or the teacher may decide that they need to present the same concept using a different representation or instructional approach.

     

     

    Classroom Quizzes

    During a unit the teacher administers a weekly quiz that addresses all of the material covered for the week. The quizzes are intended to motivate students to study for the summative unit as well as provide students with a sample of the types of questions they may encounter on the unit test.

    District-Developed Assessments



     

    District-developed monthly exams are administered to all students at the end of each of the school year’s first eight months. The exams are based on state-authorized curricular goals for the grade and subjects involved. Because district administrators insist that teachers send results of these tests home to parents, all teachers do so. Yet, because the content covered by the monthly tests typically doesn’t coincide with what is being taught at the time the tests are administered, teachers rarely alter their instruction based on students’ performances on the monthly exams.

     

     

    Structured Pair-Work



     

    Each student is given an appointment clock and is required to make an appointment with three other students for discussion later in the lesson. Once all the appointments have been made the teacher begins the lesson, providing information and posing questions that require higher-order thinking about the information. The students are asked to reflect on the information and to answer specific questions. Then the students go to their first appointment and spend approximately 15 minutes sharing their thinking as it relates to one or two of the posed questions. They analyze each other’s responses and come to consensus. As the students work with their partners, the teacher walks around and notes common misunderstandings and gaps in understanding. At the conclusion of the first appointment, the teacher uses the information gained during the informal observations to help redirect thinking, to reinforce ideas, and to provide cues that would help advance their learning. The students then go to their next appointment and class continues in this manner until all appointments have been met and all questions have been discussed.

     

     

    Collective Definitions of Success Criteria



     

    The teacher provides students with an open-ended question related to a concept they are studying and asks the students to identify the information or details necessary for a response to demonstrate full understanding of the concept. A list of these details is recorded on the board. The teacher then provides students with examples of several student responses that were given by students in previous years. The students are asked to analyze the responses and to determine if the responses show full understanding, partial understanding, or no understanding of the concept. Students must justify their answers. As this thinking is shared, the list of details or supports necessary for a response to the question is further refined until a set of criteria emerges that students can use to self-assess and peer-assess their responses to the question.

     

     

    Homework Help Board

     

    Homework Help Board is established as a start-of-class routine, twice a week. The teacher assigns problems for students to complete as homework. As students came into class the following day, they would review their homework and identify any problems with which they had difficulty. They would write that problem number on the board. A student who had been able to successfully complete the question would write the solution on the board. This process was followed until all identified problems had correct solutions. If another student had a different approach to solving the same problem or a different answer, that student would post the alternative solution. If there are alternative correct solutions to any one problem, the teacher should point that out and ask students to discuss the different approaches. If something is incorrect, the teacher should ask the class if someone could correct the problem. If a problem had been noted on the board and no solution provided, the teacher would then review that problem, suggesting perhaps a first step or something to think about to see if a student, with support, could complete the solution. If all problems had a correct solution on the board, the teacher should either begin the lesson directly or ask one or two questions as a check to be certain all students understood the concepts. As students become practiced with this routine, the teacher can to begin the lesson quite quickly as students will be able to resolve all the homework questions themselves. When students struggled to do this, teachers should modified their instruction as necessary for that day or the following day in order to review or revisit the topic.

     

    Round-robin

     

    During Round-robin reading, the teacher oversees a small reading group assigns each student in turn to read a section of the reading book aloud. Round-robin reading provides students with fluent modeling of reading, and opportunities to practice oral reading with performance feedback.

     

     

    Formal Grammar Instruction

     

    Formal Grammar Instruction is a writing practice that is focused primarily on explicit and systematic teaching of the parts of speech and structure of sentences.

     

     



    Think-Pair-Share

    Think-Pair-Share is a great strategy for providing opportunities for all students to respond during whole group discussion. Ask a question or propose a problem. Students first think of an answer or idea on their own (2-3 minutes). Next, students share, and possibly revise, their responses by sharing with a partner. Then open discussion to the whole group to share and compare answers and ideas.

     

     

    Guided Reciprocal Peer Questioning

     

    Guided Reciprocal Peer Questioning is used after students have had an opportunity to learn about a concept or concepts. Then students draw on their own conceptual understanding developed through instruction by asking questions of each other. The teacher provides students with a prompt directly related to the lesson or sequence of lessons the questions will target and gives them a few minutes to formulate questions using a list of question stems. For example, the teacher might say,

     

    For the past few days we have been learning about rocks and the different processes that formed them. Think about what you have learned. Write down two or three questions you would like to ask your classmates that will help you improve your understanding of ___________ and ______________. You may use the question stems on the list to make up you questions or you may create your own.

    What causes _____________?
    How do we know that _____________?
    Why does _______________ happen when _____________?
    What if _____________?
    How do ____________ contribute to ________________?
    How does ______________relate to everyday life?

     

    Students then form small groups of three to four and take turns asking each other about the content they are learning using open-ended questions and discussing their answers. Each small group notes any questions they have difficulty with. The teacher can choose to help individual groups work through the questions or discuss them with the whole class.

     

     

    Large-Group Lecture

     

    Large-group lecture is an oral presentation or lesson intended to present a concept or topic to students as a whole class. It is one of the oldest forms of teaching and one of the most efficient means of transferring knowledge and concepts to the class as a whole. Large-group lectures convey critical information to students that they need in order to understand the concept or topic. Usually teachers stand at the front of the room and talk to the students about the content.

     

     

    Multiple-Choice Test

    A Multiple-Choice Test is a flexible assessment format that can be used to measure a wide range of knowledge, skills, attitudes and abilities. It allows broad and even deep coverage of content in a relatively efficient way. A Multiple-Choice Test usually consists of a number of items that pose a question to which students must select the best possible answer (or answers) out of the choices from a number of choices. Items can also be statements to which students must find the best completion. Multiple-choice items, therefore, are fundamentally recognition tasks, where students must identify the correct response.



     

     

    Explain Your Answers

     

    Lots of curriculum standards involve mastery of processes or computation tasks. The teacher asks the students to complete the task and then explain their answer or their process for finding the answer. For instance, a teacher might have students explain or justify their answer to _________________. This process holds students accountable to the content and whether or not they understood what they did and the reason they did it.

    Persuasive Writing

     

    Persuasive Writing assignments require students to analyze an issue, take a position, and defend it. The key is that students have to know more than just the facts about an issue; they have to make judgments about those facts, organize them in a persuasive way, and use those facts to make their case. Through the Persuasive Writing students will reveal how well they have processed the information because they can generate new knowledge and can organize the information for a particular purpose. Students might, for example, construct an argument as to why a British account of the start of the American Revolution is more plausible than an American account, or why scatter plots are a better way to represent data about students’ grade performance on the last class quiz than bar graphs are.

     

     

    Invention Tasks

     

    Once students have learned a concept and identified the patterns, principles, and key elements of that concept, an Invention Task asks them to take what they have learned and create something of their own. For example, students might use the arrogance of a Shakespearean sonnet to write their own, following the principles of force and motion to design ways of protecting an egg dropped from the top of the school building, or apply what they’ve learned about nutrition to create their own diet plans. Asking students to use what they have learned to invent something new demonstrates their understanding of the concepts involved, as well as, their ability to apply and adapt these concepts to solve.

     

     

    Capstone

     

    Capstone is project-based and is used after students have finished a unit or multiple units. Capstones are designed to answer the “So what?” of a unit. They involve students using all that they have learned to reflect on why they have learned what they have learned, and how the different part so the unit connects in a meaningful way. For example, if students have just completed a poetry unit they will now work in groups to create their own collection of poetry, selecting poems that contain an array of poetic devices and represent an array of styles. As a group, they would write the foreword to the anthologhy in which they explain why they selected the poems and also write introductions to each poem, pointing out key features and the explaining how that poem supports the anthology’s overall theme.

     

     

    Error Analysis

     

    In an Error Analysis assessment, students are given problems and answers. Some of the answers are correct and some are incorrect. Students must identify each answer as correct or incorrect and then explain why. For example, after a unit on compound sentences, you might give students a set of 10 sentences, 4 of which are properly constructed compound sentences and 6 of which are not. Students must then identify which of the 10 are compound sentences and transform the ones that are not into properly constructed compound sentences. Error Analysis asks students to do more than reproduce the correct answer, and it helps the teacher assess whether students understand why an answer is correct and whether students can create correct answers form an incorrect one.

     

     

    Two-column notes



    A note-taking technique accomplished by dividing paper, transparency, or other writing surface into two columns. Students write column headings appropriate to type of notes: main idea/detail, opinion/proof, hypothesis/proof, and problem/solution. Under each heading, students fill in words or phrases from text or other material. Entries in right column correspond to entries on left: i.e., proofs with opinion or hypothesis; details with main ideas. This strategy can be adapted to review activity by covering or folding back one column: students supply missing information and review hidden column for recall. Teacher can ask for conclusions or relate to material previously learned for comprehension check.

     

     



    Literature Circles

    Literature Circles are small groups of students, arranged by readiness level or interest, reading a novel together. For example, the whole class may be reading novels by the same author or that have similar themes, but each literature group has a novel that is specifically appropriate for them. This allows for whole group discussion as well as small group work. The Lexile Framework , it is a great resource for identifying appropriate novels for each group.

     

     

    Varied Products

    Varied Products is possibly the easiest way to differentiate. Allow students to make choices about how they demonstrate what they’ve learned, whether they write an essay, make a poster, or act out a scene. Be clear about your expectations, possibly using a rubric; then allow them to meet the requirements in their own way. This also works well when you have limited resources because not all students need to same materials and equipment at the same time.

    Synectics

    The word Synectics is derived from a Greek term meaning the fitting together of different apparently irrelevant element. This strategy uses analogies or metaphors to connect students’ ideas with a concept. Students are provided with a chart containing four to six boxes. They are given a category, seemingly unrelated to the identified concept, and asked to fill in the four squares with an item from that category. For example, if the category is “things at a fast-food restaurant,” students might record french fries, burgers, drive-thru window, and milk shakes. The students are then given a concept to relate each of the items to using the following completion sentence: A ________________ is like a _milk shake_____ because _______________. Analogies are a type of conceptual model that can give teachers a glimpse into student thinking.

     

     

    Using Multiple Texts

     

    Using Multiple Texts is a strategy that allows students to see differing perspectives intended by an author speech by comparing the primary source of material to a secondary source of information. Comparing several sources provides students an opportunity to see what the writer or speaker intended rather than how other writers interpreted him or her. There are many primary and secondary examples on the internet. For example, a written, audio, or video speech produced by Martin Luther King Jr.'s "I Have a Dream", George W. Bush's speech just after the events of 9/11, or Susan B. Anthony's speech on a woman's right to vote are easily found in a search engine. Or, if you've just read The Very Hungry Caterpillar, use an author interview with Eric Carle about his writing process and discuss what students learned. Other options include comparing opinion-based articles with news articles, texts written from different perspectives such as the Three Little Pigs and The True Story of the Three Little Pigs, or examples of debates. Whatever is chosen as a primary source, it is important to find a speech that suits your current content area, as well as, the developmental age of your students.



    Super-Heroes

    Super-Heroes is a fantasy-based boundary-stretching problem solving technique. Participants pretend to be a fictional (or real) superhero (Superman, the Incredible Hulk, Batman, James Bond, Wonder Woman, Sherlock Holmes, Spiderman, etc.) and use their 'super' characteristics to trigger ideas and answer questions. All 'superheroes' have skills and capacities that are outside 'normal' behavior, this means that (a) students tend to think outside of the norm and (b) having a role allows students to express more unusual ideas that they might not normally express.

    Super-Hero stories also have strong elements of wish-fulfillment, and can therefore help students to express ideas.

    1. Prepare in advance a set of general information on each superhero. This could include name, special powers, weaknesses, pen picture, background, picture etc. You can also provide props if you have an extrovert group.
    2. Display and discuss the problem to ensure everyone understands the issue. It can be useful to use Brainstorming or Brain-Writing to list the more obvious ideas.
    3. Selects a superhero for each student (they can choose one themselves, or from your information pack). Get them to think a little about that superhero and talk to them about what life is like as a superhero in order to help them get into the role.
    4. The superhero characters are then used as the basis of an excursion , from any viewpoint.
    5. Start by getting each superhero to voice a few ideas. For instance, if the class was discussing the problem of how to deal with water pollution from pesticide run-off, a student from the "Spiderman" perspective might propose that she could use her webs to capture insect pests on farms so farmers would not need to spray pesticides. In the same discussion, a student from the perspective of "The Flash" might propose that he could run through the fields at super speed, pick off all the insects, and take them to a place where they would not bother farmers.

    In addition, allowing superheroes to work together could trigger other ideas. Perhaps if superman and wonder woman worked together they could produce an improved solution to the problem.

     

     

    Back to top